The Committed Man

The thing is, by the end of October part of me just assumed this was going to happen. A few weeks ago I bought tickets to an event “with the Booker Prize winner”, and when mentioning it to someone, accidentally said, “I’m going to see M John Harrison be interviewed”.

It felt like the stars and vibes were with him, which is to say my tea-leaf-reading and meta-gaming and wish-casting just happened to pan out. As soon as this year’s longlist was released, and had so many idiosyncratic and speculative novels on it, it seemed to me that if the jury was of that disposition, surely The End of Everything would make the shortlist, as the best of that kind of thing available to them. I’m not sure when that progressed to an expectation of it winning, but I think it was after one of this year’s judges followed me on social media, which was surely only explicable on the basis that they had come across my review of the novel and found something of interest in it; then when it made the shortlist, I was surprised (but obviously pleased) to find that my review was one of the ones quoted on the Booker website page about the novel, the only one from an SF-focused venue. None of this adds up to a logical rationale; the closest I came to that was thinking that the other books on the shortlist, for all their perceived strengths, surely wouldn’t reward re-reading as much as Harrison’s novel. But really my expectation was an incoherent act of belief.

And then it came to pass that The End of Everything won the 2026 Man Booker Prize, and I was delighted, and suddenly it has to mean something.

It is too neat, hilariously neat, the way this anti-narrative novel fits into so many narratives. Because of course on one level all it means is that five people decided to give one person an award for a novel. But this novel, by this person, for this award: it is too much. To agree on what this moment means, we’d need to agree not just on what The End of Everything “is”, but on what M John Harrison represents and on what the Booker signifies, and that’s never going to happen, as the sometimes infuriating, often delightful, but certainly voluminous discourse this week has demonstrated.

The quote from the Chair of the Booker foundation was, “the first Booker winner to have emerged from the bona fide SF world.” That seems a careful and fair description of the relationship between Harrison and SF. The End of Everything is not the first SF novel to win; nor is Harrison the first writer of SF to win; but he is the first winner to be shaped by the SF community and tradition. Arriving on the back of China Mieville’s win of the Goldsmiths Prize a week earlier for The Rouse, and, earlier this year, Daniel Kraus’ Pulitzer win for Angel Down, surely this means we are in a moment for the bona fide SF world.

But the broader media coverage tended to sand down the Booker’s statement to “the first science fiction writer to win.” That is a different thing, and less true. There probably was a point in his career where M John Harrison could have been described without too much wincing as “a science fiction writer”, but we are decades past that now. He writes M John Harrison fiction. The End of Everything was published in the UK by Serpent’s Tail, not a genre imprint, and is written by a writer whose relationship with science fiction is thorny; it does not mean quite the same thing as would a win for, say, an Adam Roberts novel published by Gollancz.

Although – to swing the pendulum back again – the book itself is unignorably science-fictional. I say this despite Harrison’s no-doubt calculated statement that no true science fiction fan would enjoy The End of Everything because its epistemological instability makes it not true science fiction. It is ornery and obfuscatory, and certainly an unusual type of science fiction, and certainly some habitual readers of science fiction eschew that type, but it has its precedents and travelling companions. The obvious ones are works that some might also argue are edge-cases for the commercial genre as it exists today, like Lem’s Solaris or the Strugatsky Brothers’ Roadside Picnic or various Ballard novels (Nina Allan has called the win “a vindication for the whole New Wave project“); but I think you can even draw a dashed line to some quite mainline SF, particularly the scientific-romance tradition that tries to give a sense of the ungraspable sublime. The emotional effect is different, but the refusal of explanation is cousin-like. And the science-fictionality of The End of Everything means that it signifies more as a winner than, say, The Sunken Land Begins to Rise Again would have done.

(There is also the true hipster position here, of the long-term Harrison reader who recognises his roots in and relationship with SF, who sees The End of Everything as SF but probably also sees categories as a venn diagram, wherein a novel can sit in more than one circle – but who isn’t certain this is Harrison’s very best novel, who feels perhaps that The Sunken Land Begins to Rise Again or maybe Light or perhaps The Course of the Heart should have been the one. There is a little bit of this person in me. I think The End of Everything does in some ways feel like a culmination, a closing of a loop, reaching back to where he began but doing it properly this time, rather than seeming, as perhaps some of those other novels did, a strikingly new angle on his concerns. But that sort of debate, while an enjoyable way to pass the time, is a bit of a distraction [Patricia Lockwood shut down the idea that it was any sort of career win]. The End of Everything is, in and of itself, still an excellent novel that deserves every bit of recognition.)

The framing that feels most relevant to me, overall, is probably the one that has to do with the Booker. When people point out that The End of Everything is not the first work of science fiction to win, part of what they are doing is highlighting a recent opening-up of the Booker to speculative work. There have been eleven winners in the last decade, because of the tie in 2019, and five of them are certainly not straight realism – Lincoln in the Bardo, The Testaments, The Seven Moons of Maali Almeida, Prophet Song, and now The End of Everything. I personally would be tempted to add Orbital to the list, which is only very slightly speculative but certainly scratches some of the same aesthetic/emotional itches as certain kinds of SF. But even without it, that’s a marked shift in what EM Faulds dubbed the literary Overton window.

I went to that event I mentioned earlier a couple of nights ago. It was Harrison’s first public event since winning the prize, and he was as eloquent and perceptive about the craft of writing as he always is. He talked a bit about the shape of his career and how, after the completion of the Kefahuchi Tract trilogy, he started to feel that he was “detecting the emergence of a new audience” (I think that was the phrase) in literary culture, and so he consciously designed his next book, the short story collection You Should Come With Me Now, as a kind of highlights reel or relaunch, and placed it with a publisher, Comma Press, who he felt would reach this audience. That collection was published in 2017, the same year that Lincoln in the Bardo won the Booker. It seems to me that Harrison was astute in his detection of a shift, and correct that it would be receptive to his work.

He said something in one of the interviews published since the win, I’m sure, although I can’t track it down now, about working to develop a critical language that could talk about this kind of work without resorting to categorisation as a tool of analysis. At the event, he said (with heavy, heavy scare quotes) that he is encouraged by a sense that many new “literary” writers who could handle “genre” material with skill, and that the work of many new “genre” writers meets the bar for “literary”. He didn’t give examples, but I’ll offer some: ‘Pemi Aguda, Julia Armfield, Ned Beauman, Kaliane Bradley, Martin MacInnes, EJ Swift, Aliya Whiteley. If presented with their novels stripped of their covers and any identifying details, would you be able to declare, with confidence, whether they were published as “literary” or “genre”? I’m not convinced you would. I don’t think I could. Another way of making this point is to say that the literary Overton shift is visible in the winners of the Clarke Award, as well as the Booker; only four of the ten winners in the last decade have been published by genre imprints.

But you don’t see the same shift throughout the SF world. The overlap between the Clarke and the Hugo, I’m pretty sure, has decreased this decade compared to the previous one. And while, as another juried award based in the British market, the Clarke is in many ways a better comparator to the Booker than the Hugo is, I do still think it’s instructive to look at what Hugo voters are rewarding as well. Vajra Chandrasekera posted, “now give solvej balle the best series hugo and the circle shall at last be complete”, a joke I think is worth taking seriously, given that I think On the Calculation of Volume is absolutely one of the most emotionally and intellectually compelling SF series currently being written. Put another way, one thing I think The End of Everything‘s win means, for those of us happily still ensconced in the bona fide world of SF, is that the (ahem) ball is in our court. The thing we like is no longer confined to the shelves we are familiar with; it hasn’t been for some time. I don’t yet have the feeling about Balle and the Hugo that I did about Harrison and the Booker – but there’s still time.